How to Handle Contract Disputes Without Court
Handle contract disputes without court by using alternative dispute resolution (ADR): direct negotiation first, then mediation (a neutral facilitator helps parties reach agreement), arbitration (a private judge makes a binding decision), or expert determination (for technical disputes).
Last updated: February 2025
Step-by-Step Guide
Attempt direct negotiation
Contact the other party to discuss the dispute directly. Many disputes are resolved through open, solution-focused conversation without needing third-party involvement.
- •Put any agreed resolution in writing immediately.
Consider mediation
If negotiation fails, suggest mediation through an accredited provider such as CEDR. A trained mediator facilitates discussion and helps both parties find a mutually acceptable solution.
- •Mediation is voluntary and confidential; nothing said can be used in later court proceedings.
- •Mediation resolves approximately 70-80% of commercial disputes.
Explore arbitration
If mediation does not resolve the dispute, arbitration provides a binding decision from an independent arbitrator. The process is private, often faster than court, and the decision is enforceable.
- •Check whether your contract requires arbitration before court proceedings.
Consider expert determination
For technical or valuation disputes, an independent expert can make a binding determination. This is faster and cheaper than arbitration for factual or technical questions.
- •Expert determination is common in property, construction, and professional services disputes.
Document the outcome
Whatever method is used, ensure the resolution is documented in a binding settlement agreement or recorded in an enforceable award.
- •A mediated settlement should be recorded as a contract to make it enforceable.
Legal Requirements
Courts actively encourage ADR under the Civil Procedure Rules and may impose costs penalties on parties who unreasonably refuse to engage in mediation (Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust [2004]). Arbitration is governed by the Arbitration Act 1996 and provides a legally enforceable award. Mediated settlements are enforceable as contracts.
Common Mistakes
Template / Example
When to Get a Solicitor
For arbitration, legal representation is usually advisable as the process resembles a trial. For mediation, legal advice beforehand is helpful but lawyers do not always attend the mediation itself.
FAQ
Is mediation legally binding?
The mediation process itself is not binding; either party can walk away. However, if the parties reach an agreement during mediation and sign a settlement agreement, that agreement is a legally binding contract.
What is the difference between mediation and arbitration?
In mediation, a neutral facilitator helps parties reach their own agreement; it is voluntary and non-binding until settlement. In arbitration, an arbitrator hears evidence and makes a binding decision that is enforceable like a court judgment.
Let AccountsOS handle this for you
Our AI generates UK-compliant contracts and guides you through every step. From £10/month.
Get Started FreeThis is guidance, not legal advice. Consult a solicitor for complex matters.
View all how-to guides